So I had a few people (technically true, it was more than one person!) asking me about the key changes and strange chords in the track I shared last Friday, so I thought I'd make a (not so) quick update on some of the ways I change keys in my music.
In case you missed the track, here it is:
Heroic Mockup by ryanleber
Now, it all starts with a very simple progression. It begins on an A minor chord, and moves to an F major chord. In the key of C major, that's vi (the A minor) and IV (the F major). This is an extremely common progression, you hear it all the time. What you don't hear all the time is where it goes next. It returns to the A minor (iv) and then there's a really bizarre chord (contextually speaking), an Eb major (right at an0va's first comment). There is no Eb major chord in the key of C major. So how did I end up here?
Well, the solution lies in the melody (the male choir), which goes like this:
So as you can see, the melody is in two halves, which more or less repeat. While over the A minor chord (labeled Am, above), the melody plays the notes A, E, D, and G. Now, all of those notes (except for D, D's a little dissonant, but whatever) fit very well over an A minor chord. When it switches to F major (labeled F, above), it sticks on that G, and then moves down to C. Again, both are notes which work very well over the F major chord. Now, on the second pass, I repeat everything verbatim over the Am chord, and again stick with the G in the melody at the next chord, but this time the chord is an Eb major chord (labeled Eb, above).
So, why does this work? Because there's a G in an Eb major chord! How is an Eb major chord spelled? With the notes Eb, G, and Bb! So G fits perfectly over the Eb major chord. Once we're on this Eb major chord, I simply treat it as the IV in the new key, which is Bb major. IV (Eb major) goes to V (F major) goes to G minor (vi), which is where all the more rapid chord changes happen. At this point, the new key is well-established, and what follows is just standard chord changes in that new key, nothing special.
If I had to give this technique some kind of name, I'd call it an "expected melody pivot," or something like that. Because after hearing the melody once, we know that G at the end is coming, That G in the melody can be applied to various chords, so I then use that G as a pivot point to work myself in to a strange out-of-key chord, and then in to a new key where the out-of-key chord makes more sense (moving out of C major, and in the Bb major, in this case).
[UNNECESSARY EXPLANATION:] If you're wondering why I chose to explain this in major keys, choosing C major instead of A minor, and Bb major instead of G minor, it's because of the progression that is used. If it was V - i in a minor key, then yeah, I'd explain it in a minor key, but it's not. It's IV V vi, which is VI VII i in minor keys, and that just looks weird. It's a personal preference, and I'm sure if anyone was wondering, they weren't confused by it. If you're confused now that you've read this paragraph, though, don't worry about it. You don't really need to understand the roman numerals to get what I did to change keys.
Well, I hope that sheds some light on what I did. Stay tuned for a new track on Friday (sad music!) and another compositional breakdown next Monday (again, sad music!). Also, be on the lookout for more serious music theory posts in the future, from basic stuff like diatonic theory (i.e. those roman numerals I was using) to more crazy stuff like other ways to switch in and out of different keys. So yeah! Tell your friends, keep up to date using the links to the right, and, uh, have a wonderful Wednesday! Thanks for reading!
The best thing about this key change is that it is subtle. I didn't realize we changed key until I started listening to it again after it finished, and I was like '... woah'. Brilliant stuff, arl.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant! Now my question to delve a little deeper: I now understand why the Eb chord works in context, but what made you decide to use it as the IV of the new key? That is, what's stopping you from using that chord as the new V or I and what would be situations where you would do that instead? Or conversely, if you were to modulate into a non-diatonic chord that happened to be minor instead of major, what you make you decide to use it as either the ii, iii, or vi?
ReplyDeleteWell, the simple answer is that I was already in to the whole IV - vi progression from the first half of the piece, and it was already in my head, I just went with it. I guess I just wanted to stick with it, and I'm glad I did, because the symmetry or similarity or whatever you want to call it between the first and second half of the short little piece really keeps everything unified, and perhaps helps make the transition smoother. Maybe? Who knows.
ReplyDeleteEver since you posted this I've been studying it intensely, and experimenting with it.
ReplyDeletehttp://soundcloud.com/chrismalson/keychanges
This is just a quick transcription of stuff I was fiddling around with on piano, but I wanted your input. Am I getting it, or am I way off base here?
Ehhh, well, not quite. Here, look at this: http://i42.tinypic.com/4he88o.png
ReplyDeleteNotice the melody and progression are played twice, but I left the last chord blank. Find a chord that fits in that spot, but isn't related to A minor. Basically, what chords have an A in them?
(SPOILER) Possible Solutions:
F# minor, or B minor 7.
If you chose F# minor, you can then play a D major,and viola, you've established F# minor.
If you chose B minor 7, you can then play a G major chord, and you've established B minor.
See, it's effective because we remember hearing the melody the first time, and we know what note it's going to end on, (A, in this case), which allows us to switch out to a unexpected chord (that ends up working, because there's an A in it). The last note in the melody, the A, is like a pivot point, or an anchor.
Hope this helps.
Okay, that makes sense haha. I wasn't experimenting with the actual "expected melody pivot" as you described it; I was more or less intrigued by how easy it is to change keys when you use the notes that the two keys have in common to make the transition. It's something I hadn't really considered before, and I was more or less curious if it sounded too harsh or unpleasant. But your method makes more sense anyway lol.
ReplyDeleteAh, well, what you had wasn't really that bad. Shifting a minor chord up or down by a major third isn't terribly uncommon. It happens A LOT in the Lord of the Rings soundtrack, for example. It didn't sound TOO jarring to me, at any rate, mostly thanks to the melody you'd written. The similarity between what was played over the A minor and what was played over the F minor smooths out some of the harshness. The similarity serves as a connection, so it feels more cohesive, and less like we're just jumping around between keys.
ReplyDelete